thechristchurchfiasco

"Highlighting the inadequacies of the way in which the earthquakes of 2010-2012 were handled by the insurance industry! "

Land Grab In Christchurch

9 Comments

It is not unheard of, that powerful groups conspire to undermine the land rights and security of tenure of vulnerable groups in order to advance their own interests post disaster.

These risks must be addressed as part of the recovery and reconstruction phases. Land issues such as security of tenure, land use, land access and land administration are important to key humanitarian sectors after a disaster. Rights to land are integral to the human rights of all.

I don’t know about you but ‘land grabbing’ is something I associate with the third world- corporates like the Malaysian palm oil giants buying up lands for plantations in West Africa, in turn affecting the price of food and causing high rates of poverty and malnutrition. Last month, Oxfam released its Our Land, Our Lives report on land grabbing (See http://www.oxfam.org/sites/www.oxfam.org/files/bn-land-lives-freeze-041012-en_1.pdf) which said that foreign investors had bought enough land in the past decade to feed 1 billion people: “But the sad fact is that very few if any of these land investments benefit local people or help to fight hunger.” This kind of land grabbing has been referred to as “predatory land grab”.

Here are in Christchurch ???????????????????????????????City we are experiencing another form of land grab – the ‘strategic land grab’. It differs in scale and the nature of the perpetrators vary as do their techniques of dispossession, but the outcomes are equally devastating for those involved.

The time has come when the Government/CERA has begun to ‘negotiate’ with land owners, both commercial and residential in the red zone in Christchurch, for the pieces of ground they will on-sell to big developers so that these corporates can create multi-million dollar shopping malls and precincts for their shareholders. It is clear that it will be the current owners of the land who will lose out. The Government’s ‘valuations’ for the land will leave many out of pocket.  The Crown states that it is basing its ‘land settlements’ on market valuations, including ‘recent sales, the condition of the land, insurance, and location’. Most do not believe this to be the true picture.

When Hurricane Katrina ravaged the Gulf Coast, many residents and business owners had little choice but to abandon their property and relocate elsewhere. Large amounts of prime real estate in New Orleans and other coastal cities became available for literally pennies on the dollar. Several major real estate investors seized the opportunity to acquire this property through what critics viewed as an unethical land grab. When landowners suffer undue economic pressure to sell their land at a loss, the results could be seen as more of a land grab by opportunists than a genuine interest in future development by the new owners.  When the Government is the opportunist, we need to worry.

What I am struck by here in Christchurch, is the lack accountability, lack of transparency and the incredible and spectacular lack of ‘diplomacy’. What is currently transpiring is far removed from agreed initial proposals for land acquisition and is so politically motivated as to be a subject of derision, were it not so serious. There is no doubt that it will also prove to be economically damaging to the people of Christchurch and to New Zealand’s image abroad- and let’s face it people are watching. The whole affair must be deeply embarrassing to those within government who are attuned to current economic realities, but are unable to prevent their ‘leader’ and the CERA boss from continuing to plot their current course. ‘Plot’ is probably the correct term!

As I listen to the objections by Christchurch residents I am reminded of the events that took place in Thailand after the 2004 tsunami there. Thailand’s well-heeled  and corrupt politicians just as New Zealand politicians were very eager to evict the people and have them hand over their land – the people, however,  were skeptical of the hollow Government promises. In response to the Government offers they gathered together hundreds of people and engaged in land “reinvasions”. The residents of the BanTungWahVillage in the Phang Nga province encircled their wrecked village with rope, in a symbolic gesture to mark their land ownership. The entire community camped out on the site and it became difficult for authorities to chase them away, especially given the intense media attention being focused on tsunami rehabilitation. In hindsight their community leaders say that their success was due to the fact that people negotiated for their land rights from a position of occupation, some have dubbed the practice “negotiating with your hands”.

It seems remarkable that people have to resort to such extreme measures to protect what is theirs by right and that it can be so easily taken away if there is no concerted opposition, by the very people they fund to govern their society.

Recently I went to listen to Hordur Torfason talk about his experiences in starting the “Cutlery Revolution’ in Iceland during the Global Financial Crisis. He recounted how he and the people of Iceland forced their corrupt government to resign, the banks were nationalized and a democratic process for dealing with private bank debts and a new constitution was created. Here’s the link.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5jZZ_Z6wI38.  In contrast, the people of  Cyprus put up little  serious opposition when their own Government plotted to steal from them and plundered their bank accounts – by up to 40% of their savings!!   Sh@# happens, if you let it and it could clearly happen here  –  Small, isolated ‘democracies’ are a sitting target for greedy, bankrupt banks and governments.  While we just sit,  nothing will change, so watch closely as to what our corporate government is proposing in respect of banking and SPEAK UP.

Where are our constitutional lawyers? https://thechristchurchfiasco.wordpress.com/2013/03/19/calling-the-constitutional-lawyers-of-new-zealand-we-need-your-help-once-again-in-the-red-zone-2/.

Resources

http://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/news/8493027/Red-zone-uproar-over-late-advice

http://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/business/7976410/Property-owners-upset-at-values

http://www.stuff.co.nz/timaru-herald/news/7584128/Owners-lenders-exposed-in-blueprint-acquisitions

http://www.moneymorning.com.au/20130325/cyprus-crisis-the-test-case-for-a-euro-exit.html

Author: Sarah-Alice Miles

I believe in the enormous power of the human spirit and the power within each of us to effect major change. "The only triumph over evil is for good men [and women] to do nothing". Trained as a lawyer, psychotherapist and mediator. My goal is to make my voice heard for the causes in which I believe so as to improve and contribute to a more sustainable and equitable society. https://thechristchurchfiasco.wordpress.com/

9 thoughts on “Land Grab In Christchurch

  1. It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d definitely donate to this fantastic blog! I suppose for now i’ll settle for bookmarking
    and adding your RSS feed to my Google account.
    I look forward to new updates and will talk about this website with my Facebook group.
    Chat soon!

    Like

    • Hi Cary- thanks for that. It is not my intention to profit from the site, if you wish to make a donation I suggest you buy my book and share the contents with your family and friends.
      Thank you again for your support.

      Like

  2. Pingback: Land Grab in Christchurch | ShakyTown Blues

  3. You’re getting there folks, but oh, so slowly. It;s much bigger than that. Don’t only follow the money, follow the politicians as well…….. where did Helen Clark go? Where did David Shearer come from? The UN of course! Who did John Key work for?? and what did he do there?? Have you ever read UN ‘Agenda 21’ ? I suggest you do. At the top, the left IS the right and NZ is up to its neck in this agenda.

    Like

  4. Confessions of an economic hit man by John Perkins is a great read or http://youtu.be/aqIHKWd9rSc

    Relates to many things that go on here and abroad, hard to believe but unfortunately true. Follow the money!!!!

    Like

  5. Just reading Nicky Hagar’s “The Hollow Men” again…..NOTHING surprises me about your eloquent and insightful land-grab piece Sarah. Brash has gone…. Key, Brownlee, Joyce and the other ‘Hollow Me’n need to follow him into oblivion. Still, if New Zealanders are too thick to see that the Hollow Men have “morphed” into Key and Joyce’s populist givt, they deserve all they get.

    Like

  6. Nice one ,
    loved what they did in Island, yet time and history will tell if this is a real change ? or just a rotation between the pigs and the piglets in a sheep disguise

    Like

  7. To date CERA has made a series of highly questionable decisions using the disaster situation as an convenient excuse. Not only this, but has been conducting a calculating campaign of subtle Psychological Terrorism on the people affected by the red zoning and the so called Green Frame. It has shown a disturbing lack of concern for them. It has failed in it’s duty and constantly abused it’s mandate on many levels. It is tainting our international reputation by undermining our democratic and property rights. NZ and Canterbury’s citizens deserve infinitely better. Time for CERA and it’s legislation to be independently reviewed and those responsible to be held accountable.

    Like

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s