"Highlighting the inadequacies of the way in which the earthquakes of 2010-2012 were handled by the insurance industry! "

Printing Christchurch Dollars – A Wacky Idea? Some say not! by William Mook (Guest Post)


Towns in Ireland and Britain are using alternative currency schemes to put wealth in their pockets.  Why not Christchurch?

Shop owners in the small town of Clones began accepting the old Irish pound, the Irish Punt, last March to help local business.  At first even the originator of the idea of using old Irish notes in addition to Euros to expand the money supply thought the idea quirky, echoing Prime Minister Key’s comment recently about the Christchurch dollar being “wacky.”  “It’s been out of circulation for 10 years,” said Morgan. “And we thought it would be a quirky idea initially.”

While Ireland austerity spurred shop keepers in Clones to begin accepting old Irish notes and coin in addition to the increasingly scarce Euro, the success of using the Punt in Clones itself encouraged  Ciaran Mundy’s efforts to launch The Bristol Pound, a totally new currency issued by member businesses in the British city of Bristol this past September.

The new money has “captured people’s imaginations”, said Mundy.  “Its tapping into a different set of values about money.”   Hundreds of businesses have joined in along with the Bristol city council.  The launch of the Bristol Pound had to be postponed from May to September of this year because of the level of interest according to Mundy.

The ambitious Bristol Pound scheme far exceeds the one at Clones Ireland since it allows businesses to pay local taxes in the new currency.  The council even offers its staff pay in the forgery-proof currency.  Mundy, a software engineer, has designed an electronic system to let people send payments by text message.  The local Credit Union trades the local currency for legal tender for a three percent charge.  Less cost than shop keepers pay when settling accounts with credit cards.

Mundy believes the Bristol Pound will help Bristol.  “Eighty percent of the money leaves the area if it is spent with a multinational – but eighty percent stays if it is spent at a local trader,” he said.

According to Professor Steve Keen the author of “Debunking Economics” the amount of cash in circulation within a community helps determine prices and wages along with levels of employment.  At a Just Banking Conference held last April in Edingburgh Professor Keen, who is a professor in economics and finance at the University of Western Sydney said, “banks put new money into circulation every time they make a loan.”  This adds to the money supply.  In fact, according to Keen’s figures New Zealand’s private debt of $1.1 trillion swamps its public debt which is only four percent of the private figure.  Conversely when banks make fewer loans to businesses money is taken out of circulation leading to a credit crunch.

According to Keen today’s financial crisis is caused by banks following an inaccurate financial model that causes them to loan for speculation at the expense of loans to real world businesses who are given a short shrift.  This produces the worst of all outcomes.  One where large amounts of money flow to speculators which devalue the currency used by businesses and families, workers and farmers, day to day.   “The neoclassical model” Keen says, “doesn’t distinguish between debt used for investment finance which is good and debt used for speculative finance which is bad.”

In today’s economic environment where excessive investments in speculation undermine the value of traditional currencies while at the same time taking money out of real physical businesses it makes sense for business to take control of the money making process and put it to productive use.

The island of Guernsey has kept its money creating process out of the hands of central banks.  To recover from the damage of the Napoleonic wars that British Bailiwick began issuing its own interest-free money in 1822 and accepts the Guernsey Pound alongside the British Pound to this day.  According to the island’s Chief Minister Peter Harwood issuing interest-free money stimulates growth of the economy without creating public debt and without increasing taxes.

Compared to the economy of Geurnsey, and even to the economy of Iceland, which kicked out central bankers and went its own way in 2008 following that country’s economic collapse, Canterbury and South Island ranks as an economic power house that could have its own money supply if it wanted to and could certainly issue its own Christchurch dollar to help with the earthquake recovery.

How Christchurch Stacks Up


South   Island



Area (km2)

45,346 150,437 103,001 63


1,038,400 320,060


Density (/km2)


6.9 3.1


GDP (billons) $15.074 $27.800 $43.088


A resident of Sumner, and early supporter of the Christcurch dollar idea is Shirley Marshall. Ms. Marshall believes creating debt-free currency is something Christchurch should do to help families and businesses today.  “If Bob Parker, or anyone, wants to get re-elected, they should do something like this.” she says.   “Who would borrow money and pay interest if they could print the money they need themselves?”, she asks.  “Especially if those you borrow it from are doing nothing more than printing it as well?  At least if we print our own money we can regulate its value and what it is used for.  There’s plenty of work that needs doing and we need the money to pay for it.  If others won’t help, we should help ourselves.”

According to Professor Keen, “Banks don’t have to cause crises.”  Back in the 19th century in the days of free banking banks routinely issued notes and kept deposits for the local economy.  Properly run by local business a local currency is stable in value.  Our interpretation of data supplied by Professor Keen show Canterbury could easily support the creation of three hundred million dollars of notes and up to three billion dollars of deposits and loans based on those notes  A quantity of money that if used exclusively to finance real world investments instead of speculation would end the economic conundrum caused by the costs of the earthquake, while reducing or eliminating local taxes as in Geurnsey.

To Contact the author of this post:

Author: Sarah-Alice Miles

Love to write, create and watch the clouds move across the sky - these days in the Netherlands. 'Art allows us to find ourselves and lose ourselves at the same time'.

2 thoughts on “Printing Christchurch Dollars – A Wacky Idea? Some say not! by William Mook (Guest Post)

  1. Wonderful work! This is the type of information that should be share across
    the internet. Disgrace on Google for nnot positioning this publish upper!
    Come onn over and conssult with my web site .
    Thank you =)


  2. The Crown Guarantee of EQC s liabilities is at the heart of the EQC scheme, without it the scheme is not credible. It presupposes the need in extreme events to effectively print money…something the state alone can do, though banks do seem to do thier best to encroach on that at times. EQC was originally legislated in the last years of WW2, when perhaps the idea of the nation standing united in the face of crisis was more the norm if not essential. Unfortunately the current government is ideologically opposed to the concept that in a major disaster, where EQCs reserves are all expended, and reinsurance is also inadequate, that the Crown would and should literally, or in effect, print money/creadte credit, to ensure the rebuilding of the damage done by natural disaster. EQC scheme which underpins domestic insurance and property values in this country is in essence a keynesian modelled form of statutory insurance. The printing of money in such exceptional circumstances as this, one in 200? year natural disaster (as opposed to fund fundamental structural imbalances in the economy) makes good sense. In effect though it presupposes that New Zealanders as a whole are prepared to support and to some extent sacrifice for each other in these events, rather than be each out for ourselves. We might like to think we are still as a nation and people prepared to stand together in the event of crisis, but are we?


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s